I always thought duct tape was good enough for fixing leaks. After seeing a system lose pressure because the tape failed, I tried mastic on a job last month. It sticks better, handles temperature swings, and cuts down on callbacks. Now I use it for every seal and it just works.
We did an attic retrofit in Phoenix last summer where the cheap tape failed in just two months. I've always trusted foil tape for small fixes, but seeing it peel like that changed my tune. Switched to mastic on the next three jobs and the seals are still perfect. What brand did your friend use?
Yeah, tape always seemed fine to me too but after seeing how fast it gives up in the heat, mastic's just the way to go now. No callbacks is worth the switch.