My brisket bark went flat when I bumped my rub's sugar, and a 3 lb batch showed me why
I want to flag something that bit me at a backyard cookout in Fort Worth two weeks ago. I had always run a basic salt and coarse pepper rub on packers with good results, but I swapped in a rub with brown sugar and paprika for a 14 lb brisket, and the bark came out soft and kind of wet instead of that dark crusty shell I was used to. The strange part is the first 6 hours looked fine, then around hour 8 the surface started looking sweaty and never set up the way my old rub did. I think the sugar was pulling moisture to the surface and burning low instead of forming a real crust, because my temps never moved off 250. I pulled it at 203 internal and it sliced okay, but the outside had none of that snap I get from my plain salt and pepper. Same smoker, same wood, same wrap timing, so the rub is the only thing that changed. Curious if other folks have run into this, and what you cut back on first when a rub turns your bark soft.